I was very disappointed with these shorts. Mind you I rarely write reviews and was in fact very excited about these when I originally purchased them. They fit great, pretty true to size, but no liner. The super frustrating thing, however, is the point at which the draw strings meet the fabric of the waist of the short. There is no grommet or so much as a thicker fabric material there to prevent ripping or outright tearing of the whole front waste area fabric. This happened literally the first time I wore these and the fabric continues to rip and tear more each time I wear them. Again, I was very excited about these, but am very disappointed in the downright lack of quality for the pretty steep price. Wish I could attach a picture. I would strongly advise against purchasing these shorts.